trayþely

adv.

Cl trayþly

?'pitilessly, violently'
  (Modern English )

Etymology

The origin of this adverb is obscure.  Menner, regarding the etymology as unknown, glosses '? quickly' from context and the OED does not hazard a guess. Formally, it can be explained as a formation on a borrowing from ON, cp. OIcel tregða (n.) 'unwillingness, reluctance, difficulty', but its attested meanings will not account for the apparent sense in Cl where it describes the righteous destruction of Gomorrah and God's anger; in neither case is a meaning suggesting reluctance likely. Sundén (1929: 44) argues that ON tregða is most plausibly explained as a formation on the verbal root *treg- as in the PGmc st. v. *tregan- 'to be downcast' (cp. OIcel trega (wk. but with some st. forms), OS tregan 'to grieve'), the wk. n. *tregōn (cp. OIcel tregi 'difficulty, reluctance; grief, sorrow', OE trega 'misfortune, misery, trouble, grief, pain', OS trego 'pain' and Go (fem.) trigo 'reluctance'). The primary sense of *treg- would have been 'to become tough or slow' (see further Kroonen), from which a secondary sense of being mournful developed. Sundén suggests then that an unattested sense 'grief, pain' may have existed for the ON sb. tregða, as is attested for OIcel tregi, or perhaps under influence from this more common n. An adv. formed in English on this n. could thus have the sense 'to a distressing or grievous extent, grievously, painfully'. As Sundén observes, however, it is also possible to postulate a native derivation on the root *treg-, which does appear in OE (cp. trega above and the wk. v. tregian 'to trouble, harass, vex'): this would be an unattested variant n. with a suffix in PGmc /θ/, cp. e.g. strengu/strengð(u). This possibility is more speculative, however. Also possible, but less likely is the association with ON trauð- by GollCl who glosses '?grievously' (see 907n) (an explanation Sundén (1929: 43) dismisses on semantic grounds). The most recent editor, Olsen, mentions the various posibilities which have been put forward without expressing a view.

PGmc Ancestor

?*treg-

Proposed ON Etymon (OIcel representative)

tregða 'unwillingness, reluctance, difficulty'
(ONP tregða (sb.))

Other Scandinavian Reflexes

OE Cognate

cp. trega (n.) 'misfortune, misery, trouble, grief, pain', tregian (v.) 'to trouble, harass, vex'

Phonological and morphological markers

[ON /ey/ < PGmc */au/ by front mutation] (may not be applicable)

Summary category

D1c

Attestation

Only recorded twice from Cl.

Occurrences in the Gersum Corpus

Cl 907, 1137

GollCl (see 907n) glosses '?grievously' based on a suggested association with ON trauð- (see further above). Anderson and Vant follow Sundén (1929: 43-6) in preferring tregða as etymon (see Anderson 907n) and respectively gloss 'pitilessly, violently' and 'painfully'.

Bibliography

MED traithlī (adv.) , OED traythly (adv.) , de Vries trega, Orel *treʒōn, Kroonen *tregan-, Seebold Treg-a-